Don't take it from us

These are real comments, posted publicly on social media and review sites, from nurses, union members, former staff, and members of the general public reacting to National Nurses United and its state affiliates. 

Topics range from calls for NYSNA President Nancy Hagans to resign to pushback on CNA for getting too political. Others object to how dues are spent on PAC activity and political endorsements, with some saying they don't want their union telling them how to vote. Former employees go further, describing a top-down workplace they call “a cult.” Taken together, the comments paint a consistent picture of a union that many say isn't listening to the nurses it claims to represent.

If you've had a similar experience, you're not alone, and your voice matters here. This is a space for nurses, members, and former staff to be heard, and we want to hear from you. Share your story and join a growing community of people who are tired of being ignored.

Misuse of Member Dues

  • “Why do you feel the need to tell me how to vote?”

    - Overtonseth

  • “It's cute to pretend that he's the only person running that supports Medicare for all. It's also extremely cute for a nursing union to support a billionaire who's money is all built on blood.”

    - Guaugr8

  • “No nurses do not want or support steyer. He's a billionaire?!? This makes no sense. 🛑”

    - Smmesche1

  • “@smmesche1 he legit got the @calnurses endorsement. Lol”

    - Hopelesslyhippie

  • “Really CNA is enduring the hedge fund billionaire? That's rich.”

    - Guaugr8

  • “Still disappointed in this endorsement, CNA.”

    - Shanamilly

  • “What the hell? Really? I expected better from CNA.”

    - Luckylunargy

  • “How much did he ‘contribute’ to CNA? This is really concerning that CNA is endorsing him. How can you support Bernie and then support him? Makes zero sense. I hate to think CNA is this corrupt.”

    - Tia_farrah_xo

  • “That’s all good but when you talk of taking action, what are you going to do? Action like voting for the Democrats is worse than useless. How about a mass union protest in New York to build support in the working class to take action in defense of their Haitian coworkers and neighbors?”

    - Hwbup_nyc:

  • “Ya’ll def missed on a lot of these”

    - Savior_mode_

  • “The endorsements were all over the place — smh.”

    - Editions_mundane

  • “Why do you advocate for democrats that continue to make the state worse?!?”

    - K_chav

  • “NO to Spending my NYSNA money on politics !!! Hochul is a great example!”

    - Munasquelivinlifelikeme

NNU's Workplace Issues

  • “It’s a cult. If you don’t share 100% of their views, you’re wrong… You won’t get hired if you have ‘bad politics’. They look down on most/all other similar organizations, including in the union and the non profit sector. Partnerships between orgs are short-lived due to their inflexible and arrogant positioning. You must be willing to be available 24/7/365, answering your cell phone on nights, weekends, holidays. Expect some very late nights (nurses work all hours) and occasional to heavy travel requirements, depending on your position. I personally have stayed more than 300 days in Marriotts in a fourteen year tenure. Good for travel awards. Bad for family life. Organizers need not even have a home base. You will be sent around the country to live in shared apartments with others you may or may not know. Labor reps are personally responsible for literally everything happening at your facilities. Better either develop your own leaders or hope the ones you inherit from your predecessor are pro NNU. If they aren’t, it will be your fault. Also - shut your mouth in meetings if you don’t want to be singled out.” (National Nurses United, Indeed, 5/29/25) 

    - Anonymous Midwest Director

  • “The Workplace Culture Can Be Toxic …” “No work balance here. Staff works 70 hours a week and most weekends and holidays. Staff is really competent but can look in competent due to the work load. The members are great and have high expectations fo the staff. The workplace culture can be toxic and many good staff leaves. The most enjoyable part of the job is when you win for the members. There is not promotional opportunities here but one salary continues to rise for the same work which is a good thing.” (National Nurses United, Indeed, 4/4/17)

    - Anonymous Labor Relations Representative

  • NO ACCOUNTABILITY Rules don't apply to all Favoritism - management lets certain staff get away with indefensible, inappropriate behavior & turns the other way Managers don't take accountability for their actions and decisions & will scapegoat staff Managers haze and bully new people but once they ‘trust’ you, you can get away with anything Advice to Management Take responsibility for your actions. Be accountable. Stop playing favorites. BE PRINCIPLED. THAT'S CALLED BEING ORGANIZATIONAL. It's your literal duty and responsibility to the working class. It's incredibly unprincipled to be this selfish in the face of attacks to the working class. You can do so much better and you need to, considering the next phase of challenges to the labor movement.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 11/25/24) 

    - Anonymous Former Employee

  • “Abusive and fires people at a whim” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 10/9/24) 

    - Anonymous Former Employee

  • “Evil corrupt directors who union bust and are racist” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 9/6/24) 

    - Anonymous Current Employee

  • “Management feels entitled to take over your entire life. Organizers are asked to be available 24/7 on a constant basis. Campaigns are incredibly stressful, which you can expect from this kind of work, but management doubles down by treating organizers poorly all throughout. After months of pulling 16-hour days (including weekends) organizers are immediately shipped somewhere else to start it all over again. The nepotism is insane: folks who do not suck up to the directors on a daily basis have no room to grow in their position, while folks who do are immediately put on a management track regardless of their experience.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 3/21/23) 

    - Anonymous Former Employee

  • “Poor Leadership, lack of transparency, shady business practices, poor work-life balance. If you are not liked for any reason, work related or not, trust and believe they'll somehow find a way to get rid of you! I've witnessed this firsthand with several employees” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 9/28/22) 

    - Anonymous Former Employee

  • Office politics are rough and the mindset is cultish. You're either with them or the enemy. There is no debate on anything, so just take your marching orders and do as youre told.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 8/16/21)

    - Anonymous Former Employee

  • “Management constantly denies work-life balance. They advocate for nurses well being and rights, while ignoring their staff's concerns. The internal politics are distracting from the real work that needs to be done. Over-involved upper management leaves people walking on egg shells and unable to make decisions without being worried of repercussions. Lastly, there is a better use of members dues than sending the executive board to a fancy resort with steak and lobster for a ‘meeting’.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 2/10/20) 

    - Anonymous Former Employee

  • “When Employees Come Forward To Report Sexual Harassment, Racism, Emotional Abuse, And Other Discriminatory Practices, HR Is Unresponsive And The Abuse Continues To Go On Behind Closed Doors.” “Labor unions are notorious for denying their employees basic rights on the job, but NNU takes the absolute cake. Several of those in leadership have been partaking in abusive activities for years, and nothing has been done to resolve these issues. When employees come forward to report sexual harassment, racism, emotional abuse, and other discriminatory practices, HR is unresponsive and the abuse continues to go on behind closed doors. NNU makes big talk about how hospitals and the corporations that run them are power-obsessed and taking advantage of nurses, yet leadership partakes in the same exploitation of its rank and file employees. NNU fosters an unhealthy environment and then blames employees for consistently becoming sick and burnt out. NNU is also hostile to anyone who leaves to take their skills somewhere else. Leaving this cult of a “union” felt like leaving an abusive relationship.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 3/3/19) 

    - Anonymous Former Employee

  • “Harassment, Sexism, Nepotism, Racism, Verbal Abuse, Illegal Practices And Policies, And Other Things HR Says That They ‘Need To Pretend Not To Hear’.” “Harassment, sexism, nepotism, racism, verbal abuse, illegal practices and policies, and other things HR says that they ‘need to pretend not to hear’.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 9/20/18) 

    - Former Employee

  • “Cult-like expectation of staff denying work-life balance. Such a strange experience advocating for members' wellbeing while being denied same from employer. I'm directly aware of cases of illegal discrimination based on parental status. Stay away unless you are childless and want to dedicate your entire self to the employer.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 3/4/18) 

    - Former Employee

  • “Reasonable staff ratios, appropriate working hours, transparent internal policies and standard HR procedures – the very things we fight for on the picket line – are NOT valued or integrated into the organization itself. Poor management practices and internal ‘politics’ create problematic dynamics and rampant dissatisfaction amongst staff. Staff are worked to the bone and given inappropriate demands, then gaslit into thinking that if they can’t handle it, they are just ‘self-selecting’ out of the ‘best union in the country’ - and that they ‘don’t have what it takes.’ The staff that respect themselves enough to get out of the abusive environment are inspirational to many who end up staying because of the ‘golden handcuffs’ (and a majority of those who stay are quite disgruntled and unhappy with the way they are treated). Salaries, though on paper seem high, when broken down are mediocre due to the amount of overtime required. Many cases of staff vacation approvals revoked at last minute, zero flexibility when it comes to work/life balance for the majority of staff. Cases of harassment, sexism, racism, verbal abuse, illegal practices asking hourly staff to not report overtime hours, and other unethical treatment goes undocumented since HR staff ‘has their hands tied’ and doesn’t advocate for larger, systematic change. All in all, what you read here in the reviews is true. Positive reviews are very likely written by leadership staff - those who are at the heart of the problem - looking to outweigh the negative reviews.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 12/11/17) 

    - Former Employee

  • “The most unprofessional and toxic workplace. I feel as though I have PTSD from my time at CNA. I would not wish this work culture on anyone. The nurses are great but ruling your employees by fear and manipulation is just wrong.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 10/3/17) 

    - Former Employee

  • “People don’t take free advice. I ignored the sexism & abuse mentioned in reviews & guess what I found? If you don’t mind feeling ineffectual & lurking in dark parking lots/garages recruiting nurses at 6am & 6pm & evading security, then cool. Great job for political type personalities. If you care deeply, this will be hard. Jaded realist who can game the system? You may like this. You’ll be in a toothless staff union working for a union---and get this, you basically have no rights (just cause) for over a year. That kind of hippocracy sums it up. ‘The movement’ is sadly mostly a slick veneer run by hacks who talk a good game. It’s just like corporate culture only it exploits people hearts. Oh well, it’s not like fascism is a threat, right?” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 6/8/17) 

    - Current Employee

  • “Absolutely no work-life balance. you are expected to do unreasonable turnout, constantly work over 40 hours a week, and are expected to tip toe around management. Management has created, especially as of recently, a very toxic environment. Racism and nepotism reign supreme in CNA (as they always have). Their best are leaving due to new unreasonable and absurd workplace policies and procedure. Claim to be inclusive and in the fight for racial justice....but all of upper management is WHITE.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 3/27/17) 

    - Former Employee

  • “Staff is treated like they don't have lives and the employer shows no concern about the work or the lives of their employees. They can be racist and hires very few minorities. They promote hardly any minorities. The sometime fall short on wages and deposits are not made for wages There is not worklife balance and many staff work on all holidays and vacations are usually cancelled or cut short due work.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 12/7/16) 

    - Former Employee

  • “-most toxic (working) environments even compared to service industry jobs I've had. -no room for error. -housing and racial discrimination -its exhausting working and living with fellow organizers for 24/7 for two weeks straight (we were not allowed to have single/separate hotel rooms) -Older, white co-workers were favored over the younger, people of color -had one day of basic training but were expected to provide results and meet certain expectations despite not being told what those expectations were. -Management constantly tells you that ‘you are doing great’ and ‘its not about the numbers’ but take that with a grain of salt because they do care. -You are constantly being watched and evaluated -Can fire you on the spot without warning (during probation period) -Racist and problematic co-workers -Environment created by management causes a rivalry and unhealthy competition amongst organizers” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 12/1/16)  

    - Former Employee

  • “So one of my coworkers was recently denied a promotion because of her weight. Management literally told her she wasn't being promoted because she was too fat. Are you kidding me! Get this. They were already having her do the work of a lead labor rep. They just won't actually promote her because of her weight. Labor reps spend our lives protecting the nurses from this same kind of treatment by Kaiser.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 8/26/16) 

    - Current Employee

  • “As one NNU director reflects, ‘Things are much worse than I ever imagined. I’ve got the scars to prove it’.  Some of the leadership I worked with closely were utterly devoid of introspection or common decency. In the worst cases I would go as far as to say that several are operationally sociopathic. The confidential meetings I took part in actually gave me goosebumps… Not warm fuzzy goosebumps… more like ‘Are these people really that diabolical?’ goosebumps. I’d never in my career seen a professional organization engage in such underhanded and calculated malfeasance. NNU is the real deal. Every night since separating from NNU, I’ve traumatically awoken over the abuse I regularly witnessed and experienced during my time there. I’m not certain it will ever end, which I’ve come to accept. Is that part of the closure? The void of not knowing.  The Supreme Leader of NNU has one spoken fear: Someone will write a book about what’s really going on behind the scenes at NNU.” (National Nurses United, Glassdoor, 7/29/16)

    - Former Employee

  • "So glad I’m a retired RN and don’t have to pay dues to the radical NNU anymore.”

    - Jenz

  • “So glad I retired and was freed from your radical union”

    - Jenz

NNU California (CNA)

  • “UC hospitals use GE equipment and they also manufacture equipment for the government and military. Should we run anti GE ads as well? Same with Microsoft, Siemens, Philips… the list goes on and on. CNA needs to focus on the nurses and stay out of the politics. We can start with actually getting a copy of our very unpopular contract with UC. 🤦‍♂️”

    - Mgmahoney

  • “@militantunion issues that matter? Listening is what everyone should be doing more often but this Union should listen to its members desires for contract negotiations. Ask the common spirit/Dignity Rn groups how they feel after the last negotiations.”

    - Overtonseth

  • “Maybe they should work on guidance for their members in the hospitals for a little while. Improve that relationship.”

    - Overtonseth

  • “Stop being damn political! I’m unfollowing this crap”

    - Andu_nick

  • “CNA says….and they do not speak for all nurses.”

    - Benjamingermer

NNU New York (NYSNA)

  • “I’m a member of NYSNA, unfortunately. We are nurses, not activists. Our job is to care for the sick w/o prejudice & not to bring politics into the workplace. What gives you the right to take our dues & speak on behalf of people who wholeheartedly disagree with your statement. F*** YOU.”

    - Jessenia R.

  • “There’s not a single nurse employed by Maimonides that supports this move. Once again, the cronyism showed by both NYSNA and hospital brass overruled the needs of the patients and staff. Once again, the nursing union created to protect the nurses have castigated them.”

    - Database9backup

  • “You found one single nurse employed by Maimonides that supports this, and even then, fed her the lines. This is shameful work. No surprise from NYSNA after the Presby sellout…”

    - Database9backup

  • “Uhhh. Is that @nychealthsystem CEO Mitch Katz?? Our union is posting pics with our boss? 🥴”

    - La_quetzal

  • “Get that clown President off social media. She and Pat sold out NYP! Don’t forget that. A disgrace.”

    - Murphs_mama1

  • “Can we have protection status for the NYP nurses screwed over by her??”

    - Dedee.steele

  • “🔥🔥🔥Worst union ever. Change to another. Should never have gone this far. This union fails to deliver. Look at recent history 👏👏👏👏”

    - Frank.3038

  • “time for Hagans and Kane to go”

    - Sallytwocents

  • “This shameful!! Not all NYSNA members endorses this and she should be fired!!” (

    - Hugo.stiglitz.1

  • “Hagans doesn’t deserve to share the stage with Bernie. She betrayed us. Remembers when she texted and called like a toxic ex and said we would never get a better deal… and yet, we got a better deal. I can’t wait to vote her out”

    - Kksamiam

  • “Nancy Hagans is a traitor to nurses. Step down!!!!”

    - Caaatttta

  • “We as an NYSNA also need to change the higher NYSNA starting from #higgins. We need a strong president that cannot be bought out. any NYP nurses will tell you that!”

    - Munasquelivinlifelikeme

  • “For NYSNA’s future, remove Nancy hagans . NYSNA needs a better president that can’t be bought out”

    - Munasquelivinlifelikeme

  • “A union leader that it’s a political side that instead of members. Ashamed of this @nynurses leadership. What this president did for us a whole month we were outside fighting for our rights? NOTHING”

    - Andrys_01

  • “Step down, Nancy and Pat!!!! Traitors. NYSNA nurses will not forget.”

    - Caaatttta

  • “I see no nurses who held the line strong for 30+ days without pay, but the corrupt Nancy Hagan and her friends who profited off of our hard work. This is a joke . Shame on you all !”

    - Mz_tashaa

  • “Why is Nancy celebrating? She should be prepping her resignation speech. Such a bully to @presbynurses she should be ashamed of herself. Nancy needs to go!”

    - Thesamanthadg

  • “Who is ready to vote this clown of a nysna president out of office next term???”

    - Marielvh93

  • “Nancy and Pat always there for the photo op…..threw NYP nurses under the bus. Jumping around like they did something for us. So disgusting and pathetic”

    - Leenie1230

  • “As a member of NYSNA I don't approve of this garbage post from NYSNA. The mayor is a clown and did nothing for the nurses.”

    - Hugo.stiglitz.1

  • “Frauds”

    - Jwil_80

  • “Ha! Funny seeing Nancy and Pat there after they tried to bulldoze those poor NYP nurses to accept a TA their local executive committee did not approve 🤔 Nice photo op with the mayor of NYC thought”

    - Winterstarfish

  • “Remember when Hagans said vote yes bc we couldn’t get anything better? Look at us now Hagans….We did it! Our Ex Comm did it! The rank and file did it!”

    - Kksamiam

  • “Still no apology from Nancy! Noted”

    - Jwil_80

  • “No thanks to Hochul or NYSNA”

    - Imdam2012

  • “Can't wait to vote her out woohooooo”

    - Pookielukie21

  • “Question is where r u I haven’t seen u in Nyp lately”

    - Blade2093

  • “So no apology…just back to business as usual. Noted”

    - Jwil_80

  • “an expensive puppet present only for photo ops. Nothing else.”

    - Emiliana.ny

  • “folks want me to be quite about this, but she’s just playing in our faces.”

    - Jwil_80

  • “exactly she up to say we , we , we but fuck us when the doors are close and the cameras are off.”

    - Jamaicanmami90

  • “Exactly, but we know. See you at the convention ✊🏼”

    - Sakura_luv80

  • “this is exactly what I was going to say! Shows up & speaks out for the cameras. Silent the rest of the time. SMH”

    - Whits811

  • “they’re hurting people emotional, physically and financially. If we stay quiet, we will be empowering them to keep doing it. This has to stop.”

    - Jwil_80

  • “Where’s your integrity Nancy? Where’s your apology? Nurses never forget.”

    - Nari_7_7

  • “Where’s the response to the backstabbing of NYP nurses???? Where’s the responsibility??? Where’s the accountability?????”

    - Codenamesaber

  • “So she's just gonna pretend that she asked NYP nurses to vote YES to a bad contract last week? 🤔”

    - Debtdrn

  • “Why are those nurses behind her? Do they not know what she did to them?”

    - Rebel_woo85

  • “Nancy is not a real nurse if she makes secret deals with the CEO. This union has left a really bad taste on the nurses this time around. Corruption exposed while we continue to pay dues. What's her salary anyway and bonuses?????.”

    - Arelyfloresrn

  • “Nancy, one day when you’re lying in a hospital bed, you will realize and respect what the nurses do!!!”

    - Monimayiii

  • “Always present for a photo op, we’re going to vote you & Pat OUT!!”

    - Salome_nyc_

  • “So Nancy you will sell out 4400 NYP nurses, no apology no explanation just continue to pretend we don’t exist! Right … gotcha, but here is the problem our dues pay your salary and our votes keep you in your job! We all know to vote you out 2027 respectfully!”

    - Jenndeguz

  • “Nancy you been very quiet since you strikes up a back door deal for us nyp nurses. We haven’t seen you on our lines since.”

    - Jamaicanmami90

  • “haven’t seen her on our lines since day 1 && only for the mayor!”

    - Whits811

  • “No apology??? Very typical behavior ...we need a new president that has ALL nurses best interest.. not just favorites”

    - Minibaker2024

  • “nancy hagans for real now. just resign already”

    - Sallytwocents

  • “Shame on Nancy. Prolly made you settle like she tried with NYP”

    - Ru4hislove

  • “Shame on Nancy. 😒 Girl... 😂”

    - Chicken.nut.bread

  • “She looking very enthusiastic. So who is ready to replace her cuz?”

    - Sassyqu33nv

  • “Shame on you Nancy, you threw all the nurses under the bus for your own benefit!!”

    - Leleflathead

  • “She’s whack”

    - Brianmakesbenjamins

  • “Shame on you Nancy. Can’t wait to vote you out!!”

    - Tiinaaxo

  • “Step down!!! Shame on you Nancy”

    - Caaatttta

  • “Shame on you Nancy, can’t stand listening to your garbage talks, and no formal excuse? You think things are just going to go back to normal is they don’t get addressed and everyone will forget? GOH”

    - Beika_zf

  • “Shame on YOU Nancy”

    - Leenie1230

  • “You’re not a leader, you are a boss that likes money and needs to be voted out together with your jokerface Pat”

    - Sir_tsarls

  • “Where does she find the gumption to go show her face after she just lied to the NYP nurses and overturn their mandate? Shame!!! The NYP Executive Committee showed you how to lead with integrity and honesty and courage. Learn from these nurses. Step down and please give NYP another round of hardship fund. They all need help!”

    - Itvivasnyc

  • “@nynurses President Hagans, the love and support that OUR union siblings at Mount Sinai and Montefiore have demonstrated is what the union looks like. Unlike your total disregard of the authority of our LBU at @presbynurses who represent our interests, and your attempt for us to accept a tentative agreement that we did not agree on to begin with, within a 24 hour period instead of 72 hours in accordance with the bylaw, OUR love and support for each other as union siblings is grounded on integrity.”

    - Pres_in_the_city

  • “That’s crazy making a post like this”

    - Not.kevin.a

  • “You owe us @presbynurses an apology. A good leader knows when they’ve done wrong and owns up to it.”

    - D_cilleg

  • “Hey @nynurses and Nancy Hagans - where is the public apology to the @presbynurses for the way you undermined their negotiating position with the hospital? It seems to me you AND the hospital are both at fault for NYP not being at the negotiating table right now.”

    - Oliviabogus

  • “Girl BFFR right now 😂😂”

    - Mikiyaah

  • “Girl, read the room. 😫”

    - Chicken.nut.bread

  • “Where’s the apology to the NYP nurses?”

    - Katplusmygirls

  • “NYSNA nurses at New York Presbyterian are remaining on strike despite bureaucratic maneuvers and betrayal from the union leadership. They’re showing that the way forward is rank-and-file power. https://www.leftvoice.org/despite-betrayal-by-nysna-leadership-new-york-presbyterian-nurses-stay-on-the-picket-lines/”

    - Drm_pappas

  • “very weak, an emergency union board mtg should be called to investigate allegations against Pat Kane and Nancy Hagans. NYP nurses report feeling bullied and told they ‘must’ sign last nyp contract proposal. We need answers, if this in fact is true both officers should resign or b removed from office. We need union leadership to be on nurses side not as spokeswomen for hospital administration”

    - Broadwaypop1

  • “We don’t need comments from no confidence nancy made after being sold out to nyp mgmt.”

    - Therealstephmicels

  • This lady really trying to save face?”

    - Brianmakesbenjamins

  • “@brianmakesbenjamins It ain’t working. Beyond rhetoric, we need action and accountability from @nynurses upper management.”

    - Pres_in_the_city

  • “I would think after all the problems we have had with the communications dept, yall would learn how to support your nurses in posts. Instead you’re propping up Nancy who has no problem selling out our brothers and sisters and NYP. We(your rank and file) have said it a million times and we’ll say it again, DO BETTER.”

    - Kadonnelly13

  • “@nynurses needs to revamp their lousy communications department! While we at @presbynurses are not getting paid and our health care coverage suspended as we continue to fight for patient and nurse safety, they are receiving their salaries. The upper management at @nysna remains oblivious about the real issues as evidenced by their mediocre ‘messages of solidarity and support.’”

    - Pres_in_the_city

  • @kadonnelly13 I noticed the same with the NYSNA communications department, which made me feel dubious about their ability to communicate truthfully and with the intent to support us.”

    - Pres_in_the_city

  • You need to apologize to @presbynurses”

    - 12pandesal

  • @12pandesal I want pandesal now:) After apology, they need to step down so they can be investigated. What they did was egregious!”

    - Itvivasnyc

Paid for by The Coalition to Protect American Workers.